Executive Pay Disclosure Is Changing: Why Your Comps May Vanish

Five houses on a street where only the CEO and CFO homes carry price tags, showing executive pay disclosure changes

Estimated reading time: 11 minutes

Your board wants a market number for the new COO by Friday. For years, you pulled that figure from public proxy filings. Then, on November 13, 2026, the SEC proposed rules that could erase most of those data points. If adopted, the plan would be the biggest change to executive pay disclosure since 2006. Even so, the rule is easier to grasp when you stop reading it like a securities lawyer. Instead, read it like someone shopping for a house.

Executive Pay Disclosure, Explained Through a House Hunt

Picture the proxy statement as the public record of home sales on your street. Today, each public company posts at least five sale prices: the CEO, the CFO, and the three other highest-paid officers. As a result, an appraiser can see what a house like yours sold for nearby. In this picture, the appraiser is your compensation consultant, and your house is the senior job you need to price.

Under the proposal, each street would post only two prices, for the CEO and the CFO. That shift is the heart of the new executive pay disclosure model, and it narrows named officer reporting to two people in most cases. A company could still list other officers by choice, but only with complete figures in every new table. At the same time, the listing sheet itself would change. Today’s primary tables, including the Summary Compensation Table, would give way entirely to three new ones, while several other items would shrink or disappear.

Think of those three tables as paperwork from a single sale. First, the Granted Compensation Table works like the accepted offer, and the SEC says it captures what many firms call total direct compensation. Next, the Earned Compensation Table resembles the closing statement because it shows what actually landed. Finally, the Status of Equity Awards Table acts like an escrow ledger, so readers can follow stock awards until they settle.

Three panels pairing the Granted, Earned, and Status of Equity Awards tables with an offer, a closing statement, and an escrow ledger
The proposed tables separate what the board promised, what actually landed, and what is still pending.

Some fine print would loosen as well. For example, the SEC would withdraw its 2006 list of items presumed to be perks, such as security at a leader’s home. Instead, each company would decide in good faith, much like a seller deciding whether a new deck counts toward the sale price. The reporting threshold for perks would also rise from $10,000 to $150,000 in aggregate. Separate tables for pensions and deferred compensation would also disappear. Still, material facts about those plans could require mention under the broader principles.

How Executive Pay Disclosure Changes Hit Benchmarking

A Mintz client alert puts the core shift in one number. Required named officers would drop from typically five or more to two in most cases. Anyone who served as CEO or CFO during the year still counts, including an interim or acting officer, so a leadership change can still put more than two names on the list. That cut removes at least 60 percent of the required comps from each proxy, and the missing ones are the roles HR Directors price most often. Gone from the default listing are the COO, the general counsel, division presidents, and often the CHRO.

Bar chart showing required named officers per proxy falling from five or more today to two under the SEC proposal
At least 60 percent of required proxy comps would go away, including roles like COO and general counsel.

At a glance: how the proposal reshapes the proxy listing sheet.

What goes What stays What becomes voluntary
Required data on officers three through five, plus separate pension and deferred compensation tables CEO and CFO figures, clawback recoveries in simpler form, and the CEO ratio with a new median employee every five years Full table data for any other officer a company chooses to list

Back to the house hunt. If only two homes per street post a price, your appraiser loses most comps for a three-bedroom ranch. The two biggest houses still show up, but neither looks like yours. Likewise, CEO and CFO figures tell you little about a general counsel or a plant leader.

The impact will reach well beyond Wall Street. From life sciences firms in Boston to PE-backed manufacturers across the Midwest, many private companies build peer groups from public filings. Consequently, mid-market and PE-backed employers face the sharpest data gap under the proposed executive pay disclosure rules. By contrast, small firms under 250 employees rarely price roles from proxies, so they will notice little change.

Public companies face a different issue. Because the new tables change both the timing and the format of stock awards, equity administration and reporting steps may need updates. In addition, large enterprises should expect investors and proxy advisors to keep asking for detail on officers beyond the CEO and CFO. As a result, some companies may keep listing more officers voluntarily, which could soften the data loss over time.

Why Executive Pay Disclosure Comps Were Always Shaky

Here is the MorganHR view, and it may surprise you. Losing those extra proxy comps hurts less than it looks, because they were never true job matches. The SEC itself made the point when it noted that companies picked the other officers solely by compensation level. In other words, a general counsel lands on the list only when she ranks among the top earners that year.

Return to the street of houses. Suppose the listing showed a home only because it sold for a high price, not because it resembled yours. A careful appraiser would distrust that comp, and you should too. Consider two hypothetical peers. At Company A, the third listed officer is a CHRO on a steady salary. By contrast, Company B gives that slot to a regional sales leader after a record commission year. Averaging those two figures for your CHRO role tells you almost nothing. Meanwhile, titles like chief administrative officer can bundle duties that no two firms define alike.

Across more than two decades of consulting work, MorganHR has followed one rule for market pricing. Every senior role deserves a single primary match backed by stated judgment. Blending a thin proxy figure with survey data does not add precision. Rather, it uses math to dress up a judgment call that someone still has to own.

So the proposal may push the field toward a healthier habit. Role-matched survey data and custom peer studies, documented in plain language, give a board reasoning it can follow. When sources disagree, our guide, Compensation Confetti: How to Resolve Conflicting Salary Data, shows how to choose one defensible match. In short, treat the rule change as a reason to fix your method, not just your data source.

What Executive Pay Disclosure Will Still Show

Not every change makes the proxy lighter. For instance, the CD&A as a whole would become more principles-based, centered on what is material to each company’s program. Within that narrower frame, the proposal would ask for more detail about non-GAAP measures used as incentive metrics. In house-hunt terms, a seller who measures square footage with a custom method would now have to explain the method in writing. Therefore, boards that adjust earnings figures for bonus purposes should expect sharper questions.

Several familiar reports would remain, though in simpler form. The pay-versus-performance comparison would use the Earned Compensation Table total instead of the current Compensation Actually Paid math. According to the SEC fact sheet on the proposal, companies would also identify the median employee for the CEO ratio once every five years rather than every three. Likewise, required performance measures in that comparison would narrow to total shareholder return.

Clawback rules would not go away either. Companies would still report recoveries required by a restatement, and the underlying recovery duties under Rule 10D-1 would stay in place. Even so, some supporting detail would shrink, such as explaining why recovery was not required. In addition, the related clawback check boxes would disappear, because the SEC noted that Dodd-Frank does not require them.

Finally, the market may hold the line where the rules relax. Investors and proxy advisors want to see how incentive goals and payout decisions connect. As a result, many large companies may keep publishing more than the minimum. In other words, proxy compensation reporting may shrink on paper while the real listing stays longer, at least for firms under close investor watch.

An Executive Pay Disclosure Decision Framework for HR Directors

Use three questions to decide what to do now. Each one sorts you into a clear next step, so you can brief leadership in a single meeting. Together, they turn a 542-page federal release into a short action plan. Think of it as deciding whether to call the appraiser, the lawyer, or nobody yet.

First, do you price roles below the CEO and CFO using public proxy peers? If so, audit that dependence this quarter. List every senior role that relies on proxy data, then name a survey source or custom study that could replace it. Mid-market and PE-backed employers usually sit here, because they often borrow public peer groups for private teams.

Second, is your company public? If yes, keep preparing your 2027 proxy under current rules, since nothing changes for the 2027 season. Meanwhile, flag two items for the year ahead: stock award administration and any non-GAAP incentive metrics. Large public enterprises should also ask securities counsel whether to comment before the deadline.

Third, does your board expect a market view on every officer? If it does, set expectations early. Explain that named officer reporting for roles like general counsel may thin out after 2028, and that survey data will carry more weight. Small private firms with fewer than 250 employees can usually skip this step, because their boards rarely rely on proxy comps.

Whatever your answers, the goal stays the same. You want every senior role priced from a source that will still exist when the new executive pay disclosure rules arrive. Start with whichever question applies first, and assign one owner to each answer.

Quick Implementation Checklist

  1. List every senior role your team currently prices with proxy data.
  2. Name a replacement survey source or custom peer study for each role.
  3. Document one primary match and the reasoning behind it for every role.
  4. Keep 2027 proxy work on the current rules if your company is public.
  5. Flag non-GAAP incentive metrics and stock award reporting for counsel review.
  6. Brief your board on the timeline and the likely data gap.
  7. Set a review date after the SEC adopts or withdraws a final rule.

Timeline: When Executive Pay Disclosure Rules Could Change

The SEC released the proposal on November 13, 2026, as Release No. 33-11455 under Item 402 of Regulation S-K. The release appeared in the Federal Register on November 19, 2026, which opened a 60-day comment window. Comments are due on or before January 19, 2027.

Under the proposed schedule, final rules would take effect on the January 1 after adoption. So if the SEC adopts final rules during 2027, they would take effect January 1, 2028. Calendar-year companies would then first apply them to fiscal 2028 compensation, reported in 2029 proxies. Until then, current rules govern every filing. Once final rules take effect, companies could also choose to apply them a year early, in 2028 proxies. In practice, HR teams still have at least one full merit cycle to rebuild senior role benchmarks.

Several forces could reshape the final version. SEC Chairman Paul Atkins calls this Item 402 reform the second of three pillars in a broader agenda, following a May 2026 proposal on filer status. Additionally, new commissioner nominations announced the same week could shift the eventual vote. Investors and proxy advisors are also likely to file detailed comments.

That earlier filer status proposal matters too. If adopted, it would extend scaled reporting rules to all non-accelerated filers. According to a Latham & Watkins client alert, the SEC estimates that about 81 percent of current public companies would qualify, which would thin the public data pool even further.

For that reason, keep a “what could change next quarter” note on your radar. The final rule could restore some officer data, adjust the tables, or move the dates. Meanwhile, this article offers general guidance, not legal advice. Because these are proposed SEC rules, review any company-specific decision with securities counsel before acting.

Key Takeaways

  • The SEC proposed on November 13, 2026, to limit required executive pay disclosure to the CEO and CFO in most cases.
  • Proxy comps for roles like COO, general counsel, and CHRO could thin out after 2028, although many large companies may keep listing more officers voluntarily.
  • Earnings rank, not job content, put those comps on the list, so replace them with role-matched survey data.
  • Public companies should file 2027 proxies under current rules and flag stock award and non-GAAP metric reporting.
  • Audit your proxy dependence this quarter and brief your board before the data gap arrives.

Executive Pay Disclosure FAQ

For HR Directors and Compensation Professionals

Will the proposed rules affect how we benchmark senior roles?

Yes, especially for roles below the CEO and CFO. Because companies would no longer have to report those officers, proxy comps for them would thin out, so survey data and custom peer studies would carry more weight.

Should we change our peer group methods now?

Not for public filings yet; however, you can improve your method today. In fact, an audit of which roles depend on proxy data takes little time and prepares you for any final rule.

For Public Company Leaders

Do we follow the new rules for our 2027 proxy?

No. Until a final rule takes effect, current Item 402 requirements govern, so prepare 2027 filings exactly as before.

Can we still report more officers than the CEO and CFO?

Yes. Under the proposal, a company could add officers voluntarily, although it would need complete figures for each one in every new table.

What changes for non-GAAP incentive metrics?

Scrutiny would increase. Specifically, the CD&A would need more detail on any non-GAAP measure used to set incentive awards.

Executive Pay Disclosure Timing and Regulatory Questions

When would the final rules take effect?

If the SEC adopts final rules in 2027, they would take effect January 1, 2028. Consequently, calendar-year companies would first report under them in 2029.

How can our company comment on the proposal?

The window is now open, and comments are due by January 19, 2027. To file, use the SEC comment form for File No. S7-2026-39, ideally after review by securities counsel.

Map your proxy dependence before the data thins out. Contact MorganHR at morganhr.com/contact-us to review your senior role benchmarks and build a peer method your board can defend.

About the Author: Laura Morgan

As a founder and owner of MorganHR, Inc., Laura Morgan has been helping organizations to identify and solve their business problems through the use of innovative HR programs and technology for more than 30 years. Known as a hands-on, people-first HR leader, Laura specializes in the design and implementation of compensation programs as well as programs that support excellence in the areas of performance management, equity, wellness, and more.