A Tale of Two Promotions
Why did Pat smile and Sam frown over the same promotion and pay increase? Understanding career engagement and pay perception could explain their differing reactions.
Sam and Pat are both accountants at a manufacturing company in Austin, Texas. Hired one month apart, with the same credentials, same performance scores, and now the same promotion to the next level. Each received a 17% salary increase from $47,000 to $55,000.
Yet Pat left the meeting thankful and smiling. Sam, on the other hand, asked immediately about when she could become a manager and felt the new salary was low.
What explains this dramatic difference in pay perception? The answer lies in something compensation data can’t measure alone: career engagement.
Compensation Decisions Were Solid
The compensation leader had done everything right. The job was benchmarked using validated market surveys. The salary bands were appropriate. Performance ratings were fair and consistent. The promotion aligned with company guidelines.
So why the disconnect? Because compensation is not only about fairness—it’s about alignment with each employee’s career mindset.
The Missing Link: Career Engagement
Career engagement isn’t about showing up on time or being a “good employee.” It’s about how connected someone feels to their career journey. According to vocational psychology research by C.W. Rudolph, four factors define it:
-
Concern – Interest in and preparation for one’s future
-
Control – Taking responsibility for career direction
-
Curiosity – Willingness to explore new paths
-
Confidence – Belief in achieving career goals
Sam scores high on all four. She’s young, ambitious, surrounded by successful peers, and eager to move up.
Pat’s path is different. After years in non-professional jobs and a big life shift in his 30s, he sees this role as a stable success. His gratitude reflects how this promotion fits into his broader life story.
Why This Matters for HR and Managers
Relying solely on performance data and market ranges isn’t enough. Career (re)engagement influences how pay is received, remembered, and reacted to.
For high-engagement employees like Sam:
-
Pair pay discussions with career development opportunities
-
Offer mentorship or stretch projects
-
Clarify the path to the next level
For mid-engagement employees like Pat:
-
Explore their career goals without assumptions
-
Offer coaching or exploratory tools
-
Respect that contentment can coexist with contribution
Career engagement insight transforms compensation conversations from transactional to transformational.
A Call for Career Engagement Surveys
Imagine if your organization regularly surveyed employees about their career concern, control, curiosity, and confidence.
The insights would:
-
Help managers tailor their development conversations
-
Clarify disconnects between reward and reaction
-
Support internal mobility strategies
-
Build trust and understanding
📊 Stat to consider: A 2024 Gallup report found that only 33% of U.S. employees strongly agree that their employer helps them grow their career. That’s a gap HR can fill with meaningful data and action to better understand career engagement and pay perception.
A New Model: From Merit to Momentum
Traditional pay conversations are backward-looking: “You performed well, here’s a raise.”
A career engagement approach reframes it: “This raise acknowledges your performance—and here’s how it aligns with your career trajectory.”
This shift changes:
-
One-off pay bumps into career mile-markers
-
Manager check-ins into developmental partnerships
-
Compensation strategies into talent engagement tools
This is especially important now as organizations face growing pressure to retain talent without overspending.
Key Takeaways
-
Career engagement helps explain why employees perceive identical pay decisions differently
-
Employees like Sam, who are highly career-engaged, expect progression and feedback tied to their goals
-
Employees like Pat may see pay through a personal fulfillment lens, requiring different support
-
HR leaders should consider career engagement surveys to support managers and build better conversations
-
Reframing merit increases to include future goals enhances motivation, retention, and alignment