Off-Cycle Pay Increases: When to Give Them | MorganHR

Off-cycle pay increases shown on a calendar year, between annual merit increases

Off-cycle pay increases are raises given outside the annual merit cycle. They make sense when something real has changed, such as the job, the market rate, or a pay relationship that has gone wrong, and when waiting for the next cycle would cost more than acting now.

However, most employers grant them without a written rule. As a result, the decision often goes to whichever manager asks first or pushes hardest. This guide explains when to approve off-cycle pay increases, how to budget for them, and what a policy should contain.

What Is an Off-Cycle Pay Increase?

An off-cycle pay increase is a change to base salary that takes effect outside the organization’s scheduled compensation review. It is also called an off-cycle adjustment or an out-of-cycle increase.

These increases are common. In the July 2026 Mercer QuickPulse survey of 1,001 U.S. organizations, 64% said they have provided or will provide off-cycle salary adjustments in 2027 (WorldatWork). In other words, for most employers the question is how to manage them well, because they are already happening.

Key Takeaways

  • Off-cycle pay increases are for change, such as a new role, a market shift, or a broken pay relationship. They are not a second merit cycle.
  • Every request should pass the same short test before approval, so the outcome does not depend on who asked.
  • Budget for them as a separate, tracked pool, and count the annualized cost as well as the cost in the current year.
  • Before approving one, check what it does to pay relationships with the employee’s peers and manager.

Off-Cycle Pay Increases vs. Merit and Promotion Increases

The three types of increase answer different questions. Therefore, they should be decided, funded, and explained differently.

Merit increase Promotion increase Off-cycle increase
What it recognizes Performance in the current job A move to a bigger job A change that cannot wait for the cycle
When it happens On the annual schedule When the new role starts, or at set promotion dates Any time, when approved
How it is funded Merit budget Promotion budget A separate off-cycle pool
What triggers it The review calendar A change in job level A documented business reason

A promotion can itself be off-cycle if it takes effect between reviews. For more on the first two types, see Merit Increases vs. Promotions.

When to Give an Off-Cycle Pay Increase

Give an off-cycle increase when a specific, documented change has made current pay wrong. Mercer’s earlier survey work found that the main reasons employers cite are promotions, retention concerns, and market adjustments (Mercer).

Good Reasons for Off-Cycle Pay Increases

  • A promotion or a material change in the job. The employee has taken on a larger role between reviews. Therefore, pay should move when the work does.
  • A market adjustment. Current market data shows the job is paid below your target position, and the gap is causing offers to be declined or people to leave.
  • A pay inversion or compression fix. A new hire has been brought in above existing employees with the same title, or an employee’s pay has moved too close to their manager’s pay.
  • A pay equity correction. A pay equity review has found a gap that the organization cannot explain. In that case, waiting months to correct it adds risk.
  • Retention of critical talent. The employee is hard to replace, the risk of losing them is real, and pay is part of the reason.

Poor Reasons for Off-Cycle Pay Increases

  • Rewarding a strong year or a single result. That is what the merit cycle is for. Similarly, a one-time achievement is usually better rewarded with a bonus, because a base pay increase is permanent.
  • Making up for a small merit increase. If the merit decision was wrong, fix the merit process instead.
  • Responding to the manager who asks most often. Persistence is not a business reason.
  • Matching every outside offer. A counteroffer made without checking peers often creates a new problem for the rest of the team.

In addition, watch for repeat requests. If the same job needs off-cycle increases again and again, the salary range is probably out of date. We cover that in How to Fix Salary Benchmarking Gaps.

How to Decide: Five Questions Before You Approve

Ask the same five questions of every request. Consequently, two managers with the same situation get the same answer.

  1. What has changed? Name the change in the job, the market, or the pay relationship. If nothing has changed, the request belongs in the merit cycle.
  2. Can it wait? Estimate what happens if you wait for the next review. For example, an unfilled critical role or a likely resignation is a cost of waiting.
  3. Is base pay the right tool? A lasting change calls for base pay. A one-time event, however, calls for a bonus.
  4. What does it do to the people around this employee? Compare the new salary with peers in the same title and with the employee’s manager.
  5. Would you approve it for anyone in the same situation? If the answer is no, the decision is about the person and not the reason.

Check Pay Relationships Before You Approve

The fourth question matters most, because an off-cycle increase for one person can create a problem for several others.

First, compare the new salary with existing employees in the same title. If the increase puts a newer employee above a more experienced one, you have created an inversion.

Next, divide the new salary by the manager’s salary. MorganHR treats 90% or more as a compression risk and 100% or more as a compression issue. For example, an employee paid $78,000 reports to a manager paid $92,000, which is 84.8%. A $6,000 retention increase moves the employee to $84,000, or 91.3% of the manager’s salary. As a result, one approval has created a compression risk.

How to Budget for Off-Cycle Pay Increases

Set aside a separate pool for off-cycle pay increases, and track every approval against it. Otherwise, the money comes out of next year’s merit budget without anyone deciding that it should.

How Much to Set Aside

There is no universal number. However, the survey data gives a sense of scale. Mercer projects 2027 merit budgets of 3.2% and total increase budgets of 3.5%. Therefore, the average employer has about 0.3 percentage points for promotions and every other adjustment combined. On a $20 million payroll, that is $60,000.

Your own number should come from history. Add up last year’s off-cycle increases by reason, and then adjust for what you expect to change.

A Worked Example

For illustration only, assume a company with a $20 million payroll reserves 0.5% of payroll, or $100,000, for off-cycle pay increases. During the year it approves the following.

Reason Employees Average increase Annualized cost
Promotion between reviews 8 $6,000 $48,000
Market adjustment 5 $4,000 $20,000
Inversion or compression fix 4 $3,500 $14,000
Retention 2 $7,500 $15,000
Total 19 $97,000

The company has used $97,000 of its $100,000 pool, so $3,000 remains.

Count the Annualized Cost

An off-cycle increase costs less in the year it is given than in every year after. For instance, a $6,000 increase effective July 1 costs $3,000 in a calendar-year budget, but $6,000 in each following year.

In the example, if every increase took effect at midyear, the cost this year would be $48,500. However, next year’s payroll starts $97,000 higher. Therefore, track both numbers, and report the annualized one to finance.

How Off-Cycle Increases Affect the Merit Cycle

Decide in advance how an off-cycle increase changes the employee’s next merit increase. Otherwise, managers will decide case by case, and employees will notice the difference.

There are three common approaches:

  • Full eligibility. The employee receives a normal merit increase. This is simple, but it can reward the same person twice in a short period.
  • Proration. The merit increase is reduced for the time since the last increase. For example, an employee who received an off-cycle increase three months before the merit date would receive three-twelfths of a 3.2% merit increase, or 0.8%.
  • A waiting period. Employees who received an increase within a set number of months are not eligible until the following cycle.

Whichever you choose, apply it to everyone. In addition, tell the employee at the time of the off-cycle increase, not at merit time.

What an Off-Cycle Pay Increase Policy Should Include

A written policy turns individual judgment calls into a repeatable process. At a minimum, it should cover the following.

  • Approved reasons. List the reasons that qualify, and state that performance alone does not.
  • Who can request and who approves. Typically the manager requests, HR reviews, and a senior leader or finance approves.
  • Required documentation. Include the business reason, the market data, and the comparison with peers and the manager.
  • Budget source. Name the pool, who owns it, and what happens when it runs out.
  • Effective dates. For example, increases take effect on the first day of a pay period.
  • Interaction with merit. State the eligibility, proration, or waiting-period rule.
  • Reporting. Review all off-cycle increases at least quarterly, by reason and by department.

Reporting is the step most often skipped. In Mercer’s July 2026 Canadian survey, only 30% of organizations that give off-cycle increases track and report on them regularly (Mercer). Moreover, undocumented decisions are hard to defend later. We explain why in Pay Transparency Is Exposing Internal Pay Problems Faster Than Ever.

How to Communicate an Off-Cycle Pay Increase

Tell the employee what the increase is for, and what it means for their next review. Otherwise, a market adjustment can be heard as a reward for performance, and the next merit increase will disappoint.

  • Name the reason. For example: “We reviewed the market for your role and your pay was below where we aim to be. This adjustment corrects that.”
  • Separate it from merit. Then explain how the merit rule applies to them.
  • Prepare the manager. Other employees may ask why they did not receive one. Therefore, give the manager the criteria in advance. Our post on manager training for difficult compensation conversations covers how.

How MorganHR Helps With Off-Cycle Pay Increases

MorganHR helps employers write the policy, set the approval test, and size the budget from their own history and current market data. In addition, we check each proposed adjustment against peers and managers, so a fix in one place does not create inversion or compression in another.

Contact MorganHR to review your off-cycle pay increases before your next budget is set.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is an off-cycle pay increase?

An off-cycle pay increase is a change to base salary that takes effect outside the scheduled annual compensation review. Common reasons include promotions, market adjustments, pay inversion or compression fixes, pay equity corrections, and retention.

When should employers give off-cycle pay increases?

Employers should give them when a documented change has made current pay wrong and waiting for the next cycle would cost more than acting now. However, they should not be used to reward performance that the merit cycle already covers.

How much should we budget for off-cycle pay increases?

Base the budget on your own history by reason. For context, Mercer’s 2027 projections leave about 0.3 percentage points of payroll between the average merit budget and the average total increase budget, and that gap also has to cover promotions.

Do off-cycle pay increases affect merit increases?

They can. Employers typically choose full eligibility, a prorated merit increase, or a waiting period. The important thing is to pick one rule, write it down, and apply it to everyone.

Is a market adjustment the same as an off-cycle pay increase?

Not exactly. A market adjustment is a reason for an increase, while off-cycle describes its timing. Therefore, a market adjustment can be made off-cycle or as part of the annual review.

How should off-cycle pay increases be documented?

Record the reason, the data that supports it, the comparison with peers and the manager, the approver, and the effective date. Then review all of them together at least quarterly.

About the Author: Austin Schleeter

Austin Schleeter has been an incredible asset in his role as Compensation Consultant for MorganHR, Inc. Austin advises clients on market pricing, process mapping, communications, job analysis and evaluation, and much more.